So any regular readers of my blog will not be surprised at the fact that for my first concert review, I’ve chosen to write up my recent Okkervil River experience. That’s not due completely to the fact that I love and adore them - You also have to take into account that since I moved to Chicago, I haven’t really gone to a concert worth writing up and, well, my very favorite band’s gone a-tourin’ and stopped in my hometown. Could I honestly be expected to pass up such an opportunity? No readers! I couldn’t! I just couldn’t.
It all started out great enough with my lovely date, Rachel and I, stuffing our mouths full of various sushi rolls and drinking the best cups of coffee ever beforehand although that subsequently meant we arrived fashionably late, missing the majority of openers Black Joe Lewis and the Honeybears. As for the Crooked Fingers set, I was sadly less than captivated. I have a decent familiarity with Eric Bachman’s work but really, this concert was the deciding factor on whether I pursued Crooked Fingers discography or merely remained acquainted with them on a minimal level. & I was slightly disappointed that I wasn’t all that impressed.
The audience, for the most part, was personable, friendly and seemed to all be there to actually see Okkervil River and when they took the stage, the response was quite amazing, or at least it was in the forefront of the crowd where Rachel and I had managed to inch and squeeze our way to.
The band unexpectedly opened with Plus Ones (a song I always enjoyed as a witty lyrical shout out to anyone with extensive music knowledge, with lyrics referencing Question Mark and the Mysterions, the Zombies and too many more to name in one single blog), throwing me off slightly because I expected something either high energy or super slow to start out the set (Read that as I was waiting for Our Life Is Not A Movie or Maybe or a solo rendition of A Girl In Port) but after it ended, the band tore into the biting Singer Songwriter, A Hand To Take Hold of The Scene and Black and I was thanking my brain for all the endorphins it was releasing because without my adrenaline, I would’ve been eagerly awaiting the emergence of the set’s first ballad to get a break from hand-clapping, jumping and dancing, which was a must as I was in the Metro’s previously designated ‘dancing section’.
Standing out in particular was the witty and biting reinterpretation of The President’s Dead rewritten to The President’s Alive, the raucous one-two-three punch of Lost Coastlines, Our Life is Not a Movie or Maybe and For Real which, Will said, were played out of order causing what he said would be a plateau of energy. I, however, thought that playing Lost Coastlines first really ramped up the excitement for Our Life Is Not a Movie or Maybe and hearing it live, complete with handclaps, feedback and the show’s shout-along audience gave me a new appreciation for a song I thought I’d be hard pressed to appreciate anymore than I already did.
All of this can be put aside for me, however, because by far the best moment came for me at the encore with Will Sheff’s solo rendition of the gorgeous Red, a song that holds a great personal significance to me due to the stanza about taking a dancer home and how she felt so alone. Red is one of those songs that eerily mirrors my life and hearing it done live, just Will and his guitar, is probably going to rank as the best musical moment I’ve got to experience for quite a while.
In the days since, I did read an actual negative review of the show from an Okkervil uber-fan - Sure, things went wrong during the show (Including broken strings and blown out monitors) and there were some set-list deviations which, apparently, caused some rumbles and even bassist Patrick Pestorius admitted they were only ‘half there’ after the show but what can I say? I thought they were amazing. Maybe I’m biased - They are my favorite still-alive, still-together band after all. But between a solid set, an appreciative crowd and an overall amazing experience, I’m sold. And as much as I love these guys and would love for them to actually take a break and not tour their lives away, I cannot wait for them to get their asses back on their bus and get back to Chicago.
Also - Because I can’t help but brag, nothing in the world is better than when you meet people you hold in such high esteem and they are real, personable and everything that you wish they’d be. The guys in Okkervil River are phenomenal gentlemen and I cannot say enough about Scott Brackket and Patrck Pestorius. I wish I could say more about Will Sheff but sadly, I turned into a star struck 15 year old when I glimpsed the gorgeous man and I think the only full, non-stuttered sentence I managed to get out of my mouth was "Thank you for playing Red!". (To which he replied "No problem.")
& because I can't help myself - This is proof, by the by, that I did actually speak to him, albeit briefly and awkwardly!

The President’s Alive (Live)
Red
Also, for more pictures of Okkervil's tenure in Chicago not involving me chatting up Will Sheff (although if you just want to gaze at that lovely photograph all day, well, I'm right there with you), head over to Jeremy Farmer's flickr!